Tuesday, December 11, 2007

Passing Out Bread Not Lead (OR: You Should Go Here: www.kiva.org)

For those of you not yet buying it - yeah, most (no, not all - I ain't sayin' that) of Iraq is quieter. Here in Bulldog Country, we haven't been shot at, nothing's gone boom, and we've been here for over a month. Good things.

The economy, on the other hand, still stucks. Those not employed by us as Concerned Local Citizens in these parts are farmers (or both). Those that ain't, well, most have no jobs, honestly.

So, to help get the economy moving and humming - and to help remove the ugly economic conditions under which locals view digging IED holes in the road as good-paying work - the Army has a small business microgrant program, which we've recently been trying to get running in our area. Give us a copy of your ID, your relevant info, and business idea/plan, and if you're chosen, you'll get $2500 for your business. Sounds good, right? Most common business ideas (often repeated): grocery, autobody shop, electronics shop.

Yeah, so I'm kinda annoyed that the two guys (very good guys, don't get me wrong) most involved with handling our microgrant program really don't seem interested in microfinance and don't seem all that attached to how we could improve our current administration of the system. Which is, basically, open cattle call starting at 4 in the afternoon. Oh, and 99% of the applicants were men. Which, and anyone correct me if I'm wrong here, flies in the face of successful microfinance programs elsewhere (Grameen Bank - 97% women, 98.5% repayment rate overall).

And, me, I'm never pleased when people don't like to improve an existing system (probably my biggest pet peeve with the Army). So, taking advantage of my working relationship with the Company Commander (I carry his radio. B6R. R = Romeo for Radio. B = Bravo Company = Bulldog. 6 = Company Commander = CO. He's Bulldog6. I'm Bulldog6Romeo. Or B6R, for short. Having a callsign is fun), I decided to email the Boss about what I saw as a failure to focus on women. Here's a copy of the email. Enjoy.

B6R
PS. If you're still thinking that I'd want a book for Christmas, anything on microfinance would be great. Big thanks to Lois Sacks for Giving (in case you think I pulled those 97% and 98.5% stats outta thin air).

Subject: Microgrants

Sir, just wanted to make a suggestion for any future microgrant program we conduct. I'd strongly recommend setting aside a portion of loans to be distributed solely for female-run projects (similar to how a portion of Iraqi Parliament seats are set-aside for women). Microfinance in the developing world has normally focused on women for numerous reasons, including a traditionally greater degree of financial responsibility (the vast majority of borrowers at Kiva.org and Grameen Bank are women). Furthermore, while often less obvious, women play a tremendous role in shaping the views of their children and other family members. Women are also often featured in COIN literature as " hugely influential in forming social networks the insurgents use for support…Win the women, and you own the family unit" (Kilcullen, David. The Twenty-Eight Articles Fundamentals of Company-level Counterinsurgency ). And empowering women also serves to diminish the influence of the most conservative shitheads in this society – the very people who will never really work with us because deep down they regard all of us as infidels and worse (and with women, the bastards don't even have much of a leg to stand on considering the Prophet's first wife – and the first convert to Islam – was a businesswoman and his boss first).

Just my two cents on all this, sir.

SPC Munoz

5 comments:

Landed Gentry said...

Little Bro,

You go B6R!

It's amazing how the Army would prefer to not think about improving a system. Show'em how it's done little bro.

Love,

Big Bro

Sacksy said...

How'd the CO respond?

Unknown said...

Yea how'd the CO respond?! Way to be a feminist army man munoz!

Unknown said...

i've always been under the impression that microgrants are for things smaller than groceries or full sized stores or auto shops. the general idea being that people will produce goods in their own home (clothes, toys, etc) that are sold at a market/bazaar stall/kiosk to provide employment and/or supplemental income. from what i've read on successful African programs, the amounts can be as small as 10 USD.

of course, i have no idea how much money 2500 bucks is in Iraq, but considering that in Beijing i could live on that much for half a year at a middle class standard of living... these seem more like small business loans.

i have some friends of friends who do microgrant stuff, i'll try to find out more about it when i escape from the midwest for the holidays.

stay safe!

Kelly said...

Yeah, what Scott said - I thought most micro-lending went to very small businesses, often run out of the home. You should add to your Iraqi Netflix queue (which they should start there, if they haven't already) The Beauty Academy of Kabul, which shows how Afghan women can often outearn their husbands by running beauty salons out of their homes.

Also, you go, Alex! I hope your CO listens to you.